Episodes

June 12, 2025

American Criminal Season 15: NXIVM

In 2017, a little-known consulting firm called NXIVM became the center of an international scandal. One day, no one had heard of the group at all. The next, people were calling it a cult. There were accusations of a secret so...

Listen to the Episode
June 12, 2025

To Kill A Cheerleader | How to Hire a Hitman in Channelview, Texas | 3

After her daughter Shanna was disqualified from the cheerleading tryouts, Wanda Holloway was seeing red. In her mind, there were two people responsible for Shanna not being a cheerleader: Verna Heath and her daughter Amber. A...

Listen to the Episode
June 19, 2025

Case File | God Hook: The Ohio Craigslist Killings

Obviously, most of us don’t use the internet as a search engine for murder. But there are bad apples in every bunch. Richard Beasley was one of those bad apples. When he decided he wanted to kill people, he sought the despera...

Listen to the Episode
June 26, 2025

NXIVM | Growing Up with Keith Raniere | 1

In 2017, a little-known consulting firm called NXIVM became the center of an international scandal. One day, no one had heard of the group at all. The next, people were calling it a cult. But this wasn’t your typical religiou...

Listen to the Episode
July 3, 2025

NXIVM | Laying the Foundation | 2

By the turn of the century, Keith Raniere had launched a new company that would not only bring him vast sums of money, it would also give him access to vulnerable people in search of ways to improve themselves. They’d willing...

Listen to the Episode
July 10, 2025

NXIVM | Sex, Lies, and Billionaires | 3

As Keith Raniere's company hits its stride, he lures billionaire heiresses and hollywood actresses into the fold. But not everyone is content to stay under his thumb, and when people speak out against him, Keith goes scorched...

Listen to the Episode
July 17, 2025

NXIVM | The Mighty Fall | 4

When Keith Raniere felt the women in his cult slipping out of his control, he came up with a way to keep them under his thumb. The secret group known as Dominus Obsequius Sororium, or DOS, was designed to turn women into his ...

Listen to the Episode
July 17, 2025

American Criminal Season 16: Lucas, Toole, and the Murder of Adam Wal…

On July 27, 1981, six-year-old Adam Walsh was kidnapped from a Sears parking lot in Florida. Just days later his remains were found in a drainage canal over 100 miles away. The case captivated America, and started a national ...

Listen to the Episode
July 24, 2025

Case File | The Cult Next Door

Mattie Lasiter and Ashleigh Teeter's father led a doomsday cult in Arkansas. Now they're sharing their stories and educating others about how to recognize a cult when you see one -- even from the inside. To listen to all four...

Listen to the Episode
July 31, 2025

Lucas, Toole, and the Murder of Adam Walsh | Fledgling Criminals | 1

Henry Lee Lucas and Ottis Toole are two of history’s most prolific serial killers. Or they’re liars who aren’t to be trusted. Either way, they’ve both got red in their ledger – all stemming from their twisted beginnings. To l...

Listen to the Episode
Aug. 7, 2025

Lucas, Toole, and the Murder of Adam Walsh | The Head in the Canal | 2

When Ottis Toole meets Henry Lee Lucas outside of a homeless shelter in Florida, he’s overjoyed to have found a soulmate. But when one friend abandons the other, it leads to a crime that changes America. To listen to all four...

Listen to the Episode
Aug. 14, 2025

Lucas, Toole, and the Murder of Adam Walsh | Death and Texas | 3

After abandoning Ottis Toole once again, Henry Lee Lucas finds himself in Texas. There he commits a pair of horrifying murders that will open a Pandora’s Box of trouble for law enforcement around the country. To listen to all...

Listen to the Episode
Aug. 21, 2025

Lucas, Toole, and the Murder of Adam Walsh | Bring Out Your Dead | 4

With their confessions piling up, Henry Lee Lucas and Ottis Toole earn infamy as two of history’s most prolific serial killers. But while not everything about their stories add up, some refuse to believe they’ve been conned. ...

Listen to the Episode
Aug. 23, 2025

American Criminal Season 17: Leopold and Loeb

This season on American Criminal we’re taking you inside the minds of the killers who committed one of the most infamous crimes of the 20th century: Leopold and Loeb. In 1924, two teenagers abducted and murdered Bobby Franks ...

Listen to the Episode
Aug. 25, 2025

A Menendez Brothers Parole Update

There have been a lot of developments in the Menendez case since our last update. Recently, Lyle and Erik Menendez appeared before the parole board for the first time. Here's everything you need to know about what happened. T...

Listen to the Episode
Aug. 26, 2025

Clarence Darrow: Lawyer of the Century

Ahead of our next series on Leopold and Loeb, Lindsay Graham ( American Scandal, American History Tellers, & History Daily ) joins the show to talk about a key figure in the Leopold and Loeb story, and one of the 20th century...

Listen to the Episode
Aug. 27, 2025

Kill Your Darlings

In this special bonus episode, we're bringing you pieces of our favorite stories that didn't make it to the final episodes. Thank you for being a listener. Please be sure to rate, review, and follow American Criminal wherever...

Listen to the Episode
Aug. 28, 2025

Leopold and Loeb | The Prodigies | 1

Growing up in Chicago, Nathan Leopold and Richard Loeb both seemed destined for greatness. They each performed well in school, and advanced to university long before their peers. But once they met at college, Leopold and Loeb...

Listen to the Episode
Aug. 29, 2025

A Conversation with Jeremy Schwartz

A frank conversation with our host Jeremy Schwartz about his favorite cases we've covered, his career as an actor on and off the stage, and what he's listening to when he's not behind the mic. Thank you for being a listener. ...

Listen to the Episode
Sept. 4, 2025

Leopold and Loeb | Nothing but the Night | 2

Once they're reunited in Michigan, Leopold and Loeb carried on their downward spiral into criminality. Their schemes got progressively more daring until the little things wouldn't do anymore. Now they wanted to carry out the ...

Listen to the Episode
Sept. 11, 2025

Leopold and Loeb | This Cruel and Vicious Murder | 3

In May, 1924, Leopold and Loeb set out to commit their carefully planned "perfect crime." First they had to choose a victim, then kidnap and kill him, hide his body, and collect a substantial ransom. They were certain they co...

Listen to the Episode