Serial Killer: Richard Rogers | Last Seen Leaving | 3
After the discovery of a mutilated body beside the Pennsylvania Turnpike, local investigators search for clues to the man's identity. Their hunt leads them all the way to New York City, where three more men will disappear from in the coming years: Thomas Mulcahy, Anthony Marrero, and Michael Sakara will all be spotted at gay friendly bars right before their murders. And two of them will be seen in the company of a man matching the description of nurse Richard Rogers.
Listen to all 4 episodes of 'Serial Killer: Richard Rogers' wherever you get your podcasts, or to get early, ad-free access to the entire season first, subscribe in Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or at Americancriminal.com
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Unsolved Case
This episode contains descriptions and details that some listeners might find disturbing. Listener discretion is advised. It's a little before 9 a.m. on Monday, November 24th, 1986. On Connecticut's Route 8, a trucker drives through Litchfield County heading north.
He's been on the road for a few hours, so when he sees a sign for a rest stop coming up, he starts to slow down, then pulls into the small parking lot. He takes the keys, climbs down from the truck cab, and stretches his arms above his head.
He looks around, taking in the thick forest that cradles the rest area. He's relieved to see a small bathroom block on the other side of the parking lot and starts walking towards it. He doesn't make it far, though.
He's barely walked a few steps towards the brick building when he sees a lumpy brown bundle just this side of the treeline. He stops dead, then changes direction. He crosses the pavement and steps onto the small stretch of grass bordering the forest.
As he gets closer, he sees that the bundle is something wrapped in a brown quilt, the kind of thing you might see in a cheap roadside motel. He takes a step forward and stops right in front of the quilt.
It's wrapped around something about the size of a small suitcase. The trucker can't shake the feeling whatever's inside can't be good. Part of him wants to turn around and walk away, but he has to know.
He stretches out his leg and nudges the bundle with the toe of his boot. He hears the muffled crunch of plastic moving between the fabric. The sound feeds his curiosity.
Wedging his foot underneath the quilt, he shoves, flipping the heavy bundle up onto its side and over. The folds of the quilt fall open, revealing a layer of plastic garbage bags.
Dark spots stain the underside of the quilt, and red liquid pools in plastic crevices. The trucker bends down and gingerly pulls at the layers of garbage bags, opening them enough to see what's inside.
He'd been hoping it was just an animal carcass discarded by a hunter, but what he's found is a human body, or at least part of one. It's a gruesome sight. The torso and the bags doesn't have a head, and the legs have been cut off.
Also missing are the man's nipples and penis. The trucker barely has time to take any of these details in. He backs quickly away from the body, scanning the rest stop for a payphone.
He has to let someone know what he's found. In the coming days, investigators will name the victim found at the Connecticut rest stop as Jack Franklin Andrews, a drifter in his mid-20s with multiple aliases and Apache criminal record.
Unfortunately, that's about as far as the case will progress, and Jack's murder will remain unsolved. But there will be some who wonder whether he might have fallen prey to a serial killer, perhaps one we've never heard of.
Or maybe one who we already know has a habit of wrapping his mutilated victims in trash bags and leaving them at rest stops. Maybe someone like Richard Rogers. From Airship and Evergreen Podcasts, I'm Jeremy Schwartz and this is American Criminal.
4:28
Peter Anderson Disappears
In early May 1991, Peter Anderson disappeared after a political fundraiser in New York City. Two days later, the mutilated body of a man matching Peter's description was found in Pennsylvania.
The investigation to determine what happened to him would last for months, and the only result The result was... an unsatisfying dead end.
Still, as the case went cold, investigators couldn't know that the man who killed Peter was planning to strike again.
Over the next two years, New York's last call killer would claim at least three more lives as fear and frustration grew in the gay community. To many, it seemed like there was no sense of urgency from the people in charge.
Men were being killed after nights out at gay bars, and the local authorities either wouldn't or couldn't take action. It wasn't until the fourth murder that things finally started to change.
And that was only because the killer made a crucial mistake. This is episode three in our four-part series on the last call killer, Richard Rogers. It's May 6th, 1991 at the Coroner's Facility in Lancaster County, Pennsylvania.
In a sterile-looking room, a medical examiner surveys the body before her. The man is short and would have stood no taller than 5'4 when he was alive. He's also extremely thin like he's been wasting away for a while now, maybe because of an illness.
It's possible that whatever was eating away at the man's body might have killed him eventually. But it didn't. It was the multiple stab wounds to his chest and back that did that.
The medical examiner dictates notes as she inspects the wounds, noting their size and approximate depth. The large gash in the man's abdomen was undoubtedly the fatal blow. But strangely, it's not the most unsettling injury.
The man's penis was severed, and according to the police who accompanied the body to the morgue, it was found inside his mouth.
The ME notes that there's only a small amount of hemorrhaging to the wound, meaning the mutilation almost certainly happened after the man died. It doesn't make it any easier to stomach, though.
The man's body was discovered less than 24 hours ago, wrapped in eight heavy-duty trash bags at a rest stop off the Pennsylvania Turnpike. After investigators were called to the scene, the body was brought here to the morgue.
None of the cops arrived and a vehicle was spaced to transport a dead body, so the maintenance worker who made the grisly discovery had to use his truck.
Given the state of rigor mortis, the ME estimates that the time of death was about 36 hours before the man was found. As to who this man is, there are few clues.
He has wide set eyes, large ears, and a thick swoop of hair high up on his head, but he was found naked, with no sign of identification anywhere at the rest stop.
So, as the medical examiner finishes her notes, she gives the man his temporary name, John Doe. In the days after discovering the John Doe off the Pennsylvania Turnpike, detectives from the state police investigate his death as a homicide.
How he died is obvious even before the autopsy is complete, but who killed him is a mystery, as is where the murder took place.
The way the blood is pooled inside the man's body suggests that he was moved a couple of times before being dumped in the trash, so it's not likely he was attacked at the rest stop.
Investigators believe that the man's identity is key to answering all of these questions, so they cast a wide net to cover as many bases as possible.
Given the man's height, an early guess is that he was a jockey, so officers visit local race courses to find out if any riders have been absent recently.
But that search proves fruitless, so an artist sketches the man's face, which is printed on flyers to distribute throughout the county. These posters are hung prominently in the windows of toll booths, where thousands of people see them every day.
Almost as soon as the sketch goes up, a tip comes in from members of a National Guard unit out of Philly. The men call the police to report that the picture looks a lot like someone from their unit, Peter Anderson.
As investigators compare their John Doe's teeth with National Guard dental records, an assortment of men's clothing, travelers checks and identification cards bearing Peter's name is found further along the turnpike.
With the victim's identity now confirmed, detectives start looking into Peter's life, retracing his steps to try and find out what happened to him. Early on, it's clear to investigators that 54-year-old Peter wasn't entirely straight.
Their first clue is that although he'd married two women in his life, Peter was a regular at plenty of Philadelphia's gay establishments. His favorites were piano bars, but so long as it was somewhere he could get a drink, he was happy.
The next indicator about Peter's sexuality is evidence in his apartment that he recently hosted a male house guest and that the two had sex. Thirdly, there's Tony Brooks.
One or two tips come in that suggest Peter was last seen leaving Philadelphia with 26-year-old Tony, another member of that National Guard troop. He's also a closeted gay man running for his seat on Philadelphia City Council.
On May 3rd, he and Peter drove to New York City for a fundraiser, which is where they separated. This information leads detectives to Manhattan, where they speak with his old friend and one-time lover, Anthony Hoyt.
He tells them about leaving the fundraiser with Peter, then eventually putting him in a cab to the Waldorf Astoria. But that's where the trail goes cold. Investigators have no luck finding anyone who saw Peter after he left the hotel.
Meanwhile, forensic investigators have been working a different angle. A fingerprint examiner takes the trash bags that held Peter's body and uses a technique involving superglue to lift prints from the plastic.
They're able to feed 28 fingerprints and three palm prints into the state databases of Pennsylvania, New York, New Jersey and Virginia. Unfortunately, there's not a single match. And that's where the investigation stalls.
Without more evidence to guide them, Pennsylvania's state police are forced to move on to other cases.
11:47
Thomas Mulcahy Murder
It's not until the summer of 1992 that everything changes. In July of 92, Thomas Mulcahy is in New York City for work. A tech salesman, 57-year-old Tom, travels often, which gives him plenty of opportunities to indulge in his attraction to men.
He usually adds an extra day to the end of his business trips, so that he can visit a couple of gay bars in whichever city he's in. Then he'd go home to Sudbury, Massachusetts, to his wife and children.
Margaret, his wife of 30-odd years, knows all about Tom's extracurriculars. At least she has for about a year now. Last summer, she found a flyer for a gay bar in one of his suit pockets.
They discussed it at marriage counseling, but it's never seemed to be a deal breaker for Margaret. So on July 8th, the last night of his trip, Tom heads to the townhouse bar on the Upper East Side.
It's here that he meets Douglas Gibson, a blonde 20-something who lives just a few doors down the block. He's a regular at the bar because it's a favorite of older men, which is exactly Doug's type.
When Doug's introduced to Tom by a mutual friend, he's immediately attracted. They chat and flirt for a while, though Tom seems to have trouble focusing on Doug. His eyes keep getting drawn to another man across the room.
Doug doesn't take this personally. Everyone's got their type, and it seems he's not Tom's. Still, he promises to stick around the bar for a while in case things don't pan out with this other guy.
Then he heads downstairs to the bar's front room and has a drink on his own. About 20 minutes later, he returns to check on Tom and his mystery man. They are deep in conversation.
Doug takes a few seconds to check out the competition. The other man is older than Doug, but younger than Tom. Probably somewhere in his 30s, with brown hair, soft build, and an unremarkable face.
Doug's seen him at the bar plenty of times, though they've never spoken. Seems like they both like the same kind of men. Still, Doug doesn't give up.
He heads back downstairs for one more drink. When he returns for a final check on Tom, both he and the brunette are gone. He can't say for sure if they left together, but that seems the most likely scenario.
Shrugging off his strikeout, Doug goes home alone that night, not realizing that he's just watched a killer seduce his next victim. The following night, Margaret Mulcahy sits at home in Sudbury, waiting for her husband to come back home.
The last time they spoke on the phone, Tom had assured her that he'd be here in time for dinner, but he never shows. Margaret sits patiently in the living room, long past when she expected his car to pull into the driveway.
At 11 p.m., she calls Tom's hotel in Manhattan. They tell her that he definitely checked in, but didn't check out. When they go to look in his room, they find only his clothes and a suitcase.
Now, Margaret's officially worried, so she calls one of Tom's colleagues, who says he's got no idea why he wouldn't have come home.
Her next call is to the NYPD, but they tell Margaret that she should file a missing persons report with her local police. Margaret spends a sleepless night alone in bed, vowing to head to the Sudbury Police Station the next day.
It's the morning of July 10th, two days since Tom was seen at the townhouse.
In a maintenance yard belonging to the New Jersey Department of Transportation, trash collectors Wayne Luker and Theodore Doyle are unloading their haul from their first round of the day.
After they clocked in at 7.30, the men visited rest stops all over Southampton Township, emptying trash barrels ahead of the busy weekend traffic. In the Lebanon State Forest, they'd grab bags from the Butler Place rest stop.
Most of the bags were the standard-issue tan plastic that the department uses. But there were a few white ones sitting next to one of the trash barrels. At least one of those had been leaking blood.
But the rest area isn't far from a popular fishing spot, and it's not unusual for fishermen to dump some of their waste as they drive home. So Wayne and Theodore threw the bags into their pickup with all the rest.
Now that they're unloading the couple dozen bags into a dumpster, though, it's clear that something's wrong. When Wayne picks up one of the white bags, it's unusually heavy like it's got someone's discarded Halloween pumpkin inside.
Only it's the middle of summer, and whatever's in the bag is a soft pinkish color. Unable to ignore the twisting suspicion in his gut, Wayne sets the bag down and pulls the drawstring top until he can see inside.
He stares in horror for a couple of seconds, blinking to make sure he's not seeing things. Then he yells out to Theodore to call the police. He's just found a human head.
In a few hours, another pair of maintenance workers will find more strangely heavy trash bags, this time black plastic. When one of the men opens a bag to see what's inside, he discovers the nauseating sight of a pair of human legs.
Not long after severed human remains are found at two different New Jersey rest stops, Margaret arrives at the Sudbury Police Station, some 300 miles away. Inside, she has to file a report about her missing husband.
When the officer hears the name Thomas Mulcahy, he looks up from his notes, then asked Margaret to take a seat for a moment.
Minutes later, a detective brings her back to a small interview room, where he tells her their station received a phone call from New Jersey State Police only a few minutes ago. Somberly, the detective tells her, ma'am, we found your husband.
From the way the man speaks, Margaret already knows, Tom is dead, and the life she's lived for three decades has come to an end. It's July 11th, 1981. Thomas Mulcahy's remains were just found yesterday, distributed among six plastic trash bags.
Now, the ghost white body parts are lying on a cold steel table inside a morgue in Newark, New Jersey. Cause of death was a stab wound to the heart with several other stab wounds around the torso. But that's the least remarkable detail of this crime.
Beginning with the head, a medical examiner takes careful notes on the condition of each of the pieces and the disturbing way they were separated. See, the dismemberment of a body is quite a rare occurrence when it comes to murder.
It's usually something a criminal does to make disposal of evidence easier. But this particular case is even more unusual because of the precision the killer used. This body wasn't simply hacked apart with an ax or a carving knife.
Now, whoever did this knew what they were doing. The head was removed at the neck, the killer cutting carefully through the vocal cords at the fourth cervical vertebra.
The arms were then disarticulated at the shoulder, meaning the killer opted to separate the body at the joints rather than cleaving through the bone.
The torso was separated into two pieces, upper and lower, with the intestines placed in a bag of their own. The legs were disarticulated cleanly at the femur.
This act, disarticulation, tells the ME that the culprit has an intimate knowledge of human anatomy. That suggests at least one thing about the killer. They're likely someone working in the medical field.
But there are several other curious details the killer left behind. The first is that there's a patch of skin missing from Tom's neck. It turns up in the bag with another body part and contains what looks like a bite mark.
There are also ligature marks from a piece of rope or string around Tom's wrists, knees and ankles suggesting that he was restrained before or at the time of his death.
Following the dismemberment, the killer carefully washed his victim, presumably to dispose of evidence and to make the bagging process cleaner. They also double bagged the body parts and tied them with double knots.
Clearly, this was an individual with a fastidious eye for detail. They'd even placed newspaper inside the bags to help stop any remaining blood from leaking out. As the medical examiner finishes the autopsy, one thing is clear to her.
Thomas Mulcahy wasn't this killer's first victim, and he probably won't be the last. As Tom's loved ones come to terms with his horrific murder, investigators from the New Jersey State Police sort through the evidence to try and find the killer.
Unlike with Peter Anderson, human remains weren't the only thing in the bags that held Tom's body. In one of the bags was a striped shower curtain, a king-size fitted sheet, latex gloves, and four straight black hairs.
Elsewhere were Tom's briefcase and wallet and a compass saw.
The saw is almost certainly what was used to dismember the body, and its inclusion with the victim's remains and identification suggests to detectives that their killer is confident they won't get caught. But investigators aren't intimidated.
They successfully extract DNA from one of the surgical gloves, which they enter into the FBI's combined DNA index system.
It returns with no matches, though, and attempts to lift prints from the trash bags fail due to a mistake during the process or flaw in the machine. Still, it's not all bad news.
The shower curtain and bedsheet from the bags are both generic enough to have come from any number of stores, but the latex gloves and compass saw are another matter.
The gloves were wrapped in a plastic bag that had a skew number on it, that's easily traced to a CVS on Staten Island. The saw has a sticker on the handle that shows it came from the Pergamon Hardware Chain.
There are only two of those on Staten Island, and one is just across the street from that CVS. And those newspapers that were stuffed inside the bags to absorb the blood, they were all New York publications.
So suddenly, investigators are confident they're criminal as a New Yorker, probably someone who lives on Staten Island. They're also able to retrace Tom's movements using information from his colleagues in his bank transactions.
That leads them to the Townhouse Bar and to Douglas Gibson. For a brief moment, the detectives consider Doug a suspect, but he doesn't own a car, meaning that he couldn't easily have moved body parts to the New Jersey Turnpike.
Plus, bartenders confirm that Doug was at Townhouse long after they last saw Tom there.
This is all promising information to have, but the various leads all seem to dry up here, with Staten Island and its 500,000 residents, with an Upper East Side piano bar famous for its discreet patrons, and with a dead body in pieces.
24:20
Cases Connected
But when investigators feed the details of the case into the VICAP database, the story gets more complicated. For a little context, the Violent Criminal Apprehension Program, or VICAP, is a relatively new tool.
It was launched in 1985 and acts as a central hub for law enforcement agencies to more easily compare data about their cases.
Prior to VICAP's creation, investigators would have to rely on newspapers if they wanted to find out if there were any cases that resembled theirs.
Or they need to reach out to other jurisdictions individually to find out if anything sounded familiar. But now, the New Jersey State Police input every detail of Mulcahy's murder into the database.
And they receive word of an eerily similar crime that happened nearby just one year ago, the murder of Peter Anderson. Now, you and I saw that coming, but the Pennsylvania State Police are surprised when their New Jersey colleagues reach out.
Despite how common they are in popular culture, serial killers are a rarity. So, unless there's clear evidence to the contrary, no investigator goes into a murder case thinking they've got a serial killer on their hands.
Now, though, Pennsylvania's cops have to re-evaluate everything they know about Peter's murder, and decide if their killer might be the same one who killed Thomas Mulcahy.
While New Jersey and Pennsylvania State Police work together to try and connect their cases, New York City remains blissfully unaware that there's a potential serial killer on the loose.
The NYPD know about the murder investigations because both teams of out-of-state cops called to give them a heads up when they came to Manhattan to chase down their leads.
But with no hard evidence that either crime took place in the city, the local cops aren't compelled to act. It's hard to blame them.
By the end of 1992, there will have been close to 2400 murders in New York City, which is more than enough for the NYPD to deal with. Still, this means that the people who are most in danger of falling prey to this killer are left in the dark.
In particular, patrons of the townhouse bar seem the most likely to encounter the killer. You might expect news of the murders to affect the bar's business in some way, but few of the regulars seem to know about what's going on.
Luckily for them, the killer's next victim won't be someone who drinks at townhouse. He will be someone who hangs out in the neighborhood, though.
27:06
Anthony Marrero Found
The last time Anthony Marrero is seen alive is May 5, 1993, about 10 months after Thomas Mulcahy's murder. That day, 43-year-old Anthony runs into his friend Carlos at the Port Authority bus terminal near Times Square.
Anthony, who is a little bit high at the time, tells Carlos that he is going to go to the village to work, then heads off. This isn't unusual behavior for Anthony. He gets by as a sex worker, and one of his chief haunts is Port Authority.
The place is a hotspot for people looking to pick up John's. Plenty of the sex workers can make a quick 10 bucks at the building's many stairwells and bathrooms. Presumably, that was Anthony's plan on the 5th.
But he didn't stay at Port Authority that day. Local police are known to patrol the building, cracking down on people charging and paying for sex. That's probably why he left for a different part of the city.
Anthony's known to also hang out on 53rd Street between 2nd and 3rd avenues. He sometimes waits on that block, which is only a few minutes walk from the townhouse.
That puts him in a pretty good position to pick up some of the older men who might leave the bar alone. Remember, the townhouse is a place where dignified, sometimes closeted men go to meet younger guys. Some of them are sex workers like Anthony.
Only Anthony's a lot older than his colleagues who work the townhouse. And he's probably not polished enough to easily fit in there either.
He'd probably even stand out if he loitered too close to the bar, which is in a pretty buttoned up, mostly straight neighborhood.
So he waits a couple of blocks away, hoping to catch the eye of a generous, possibly lonely man leaving at the end of the night. It's likely there that he meets his killer sometime on May 6th.
It's not until the 10th that Anthony's found in Whiting, New Jersey. That morning, a man calls the police to tell them he's found human remains in a wooded area close to his home.
Just like Thomas Mulcahy, Anthony's been stabbed to death and his body cut into seven pieces, each of them carefully washed and drained of their blood.
Investigators notice ligature marks around his ankles and find a clothesline underneath one of his arms. There's no wallet or ID this time, but detectives take fingerprints and match them to Anthony's arrest records in Philadelphia and New York.
Unfortunately, New Jersey investigators aren't able to discover much more about Anthony. What they do learn is that he was a free spirit who struggled with substances and didn't have a permanent home of his own.
Working from Anthony's arrest record, they had to port authority to find anything they can. That eventually leads them to Carlos Santiago, who last saw his friend on the 5th.
He tells them that Anthony sometimes stayed with him when he had nowhere else to go. He also tells them about Anthony hanging out in the vicinity of townhouse. But that's about all he knows.
As for who killed Anthony, investigators managed to lift two fingerprints and a palm print from one of the garbage bags his remains were found in. But none of them match anything in the system.
Now, by this stage, it's unclear whether Anthony's case has been linked with the murders of Peter Anderson and Thomas Mulcahy. But if it has, then it doesn't seem to add a greater sense of urgency to the investigation.
After just a few weeks, detectives assigned to the case need to move on to others, and it's hard for them to argue against being reassigned. What few leads they had have gone nowhere, and there are new crimes popping up every week.
What choice do they have? Unfortunately, it's a choice that allows an act of Serial Killer free reign for a little longer, and no one is sounding the alarm.
31:29
Michael Sakaraʼs Fate
It's sometime after 3 a.m. on July 30th, 1993, just under 3 months since the murder of Anthony Marrero. In Greenwich Village, things at the Five Oaks are winding down for the night.
Bartender Lisa Hall is getting ready for last call so she can close up by 4. Having been around since the 1940s, the Oaks is an establishment in the village. It's also a haven for the gay community.
Back when it opened, the owner's wife actively cultivated a gay clientele. It's not hard to see the appeal, really.
It's a basement bar with no windows, which makes it a safe place for people to congregate and show affection without anyone seeing them from the street. There's a dining room on one half of the building, and the other is a lively piano bar.
Jazz pianist Marie Blake plays most nights, surrounded by her adoring fans as she fills the space with Broadway tunes and other classics. She's been here for 25 years.
Michael Sakara isn't in Oak's Institution the same way Marie is, but he's there just as often as she is. Tonight he's sitting at the bar.
He always sits at the bar, always on the same stool at the end, where he can chat with Lisa, sing along with Marie, and drink whiskey until closing time. Other regulars know and love Michael.
He's a six-foot tall, 200-pound teddy bear of a guy, beard and all.
He can down cut his sark and water like nobody's business, lets Lisa read him his horoscope every night, and always, always asks Marie to play I'll Be Seeing You right before closing.
It's about 3.30 when a man walks down the stairs from the street and steps inside the Oaks. He's in his early 30s. He's got an average build with wavy hair and brown glassy eyes.
He's wearing a blue button-down shirt with the sleeves rolled up. In other words, he's completely unremarkable. The kind of guy you'd forget as soon as you looked away.
At first, Lisa only clocks him because he's walked in so close to closing. Then he does something strange that really catches her attention. He walks across the mostly empty room and sits on the stool right next to Michael.
Almost every other seat in the place is free, but he chooses that one. Lisa turns to take another customer's order, and when she turns back, Michael and this guy are deep in conversation. They wave her over and Michael introduces the man as Mark.
He's a nurse at St. Vincent's, he explains. Mark orders a couple of scotch and waters right before last call.
But Lisa notices that he doesn't seem to touch them. Then, right after 4 a.m., Michael and Mark get up to leave while Lisa finishes closing down the bar. She says good night, not realizing she won't see her favorite customer ever again.
Lisa Hall isn't the last person to see Michael Sakara alive. At least two men panhandling outside the Five Oaks will later report seeing him with another man. Their description of this man will vary, but the basic beats are consistent.
Michael leaves the bar with a slightly younger, slightly shorter man. The two of them get into a parked car right out front, then drive away. The next time anyone will see Michael is the next day, on July 31st.
Not long after sunrise, a man in Haverstraw Bay, New York, is at a spot overlooking the Hudson River.
He's out early, searching trash cans for bottles and cans to recycle, when he finds a briefcase, as well as a bag that holds men's clothing and a wallet. The ID in the wallet is Michael's, but there's no sign of its owner.
Just a few hours later, Ronald Colandrea shows up for work. He runs a hot dog truck in Rockland County, about 50 miles north of where Michael's belongings just showed up. Ron Stand is a family business, and he's here pretty much every day.
He was here at closing last night, so he knows that the trash can right next to the truck was only about a third full when he left. But when he walks by, he can see that the barrel is nearly full. That's not right, and it's annoying.
Ron's customers need these trash cans, which is why he ensures they're emptied regularly. Thinking some person must have come to dump their household garbage here, he takes a closer look at the plastic bags heaped inside the can.
He's hoping he might find an address, and then he can drive the trash back to its owner. The topmost bag is one of those dark green ones, the plastic tied in a tight knot. Ron unties it and takes an immediate step back from the trash can.
He takes a second to catch his breath, and then he moves closer to take another look in the bag. Turns out he wasn't imagining it. There really is a human head in there.
With a rising sense of dread, Ron reaches down and unties another bag to find a pair of arms, each neatly cut at the shoulder joint. At this point, he knows that he has to alert the police, but he's stuck.
He doesn't have a phone, and he doesn't want to leave the remains out in the open like this. So he waits patiently by his truck until a customer pulls in for an early lunch just after 11.
Ron explains what he's found and asks them to fetch the police, which they do. Pretty soon, a detective from the Rockland County DA's office is on the scene, and the investigation begins.
A stretch of road has shut down so police can search for the rest of the remains, because so far, all they have is a head and arms. Thanks to the man who found Michael's ID a few hours ago, investigators are quickly able to confirm who the victim is.
Armed with that information, they head to Manhattan to find out exactly what happened. It's clear that Michael's studio apartment wasn't the crime scene.There's no blood, no signs of a struggle, but a friendly gregarious man like Michael leaves behind a bright trail to follow. They put together a picture of their victim, speaking with his family members, his ex-boyfriend and his colleagues.
Detectives find their way to the Five Oaks, where they learn about his habits, how often he's at the bar, and who he was with on the last night anyone saw him. It's a promising start in the hunt for his killer.
38:23
Call to Action
But what's perhaps even more helpful is that Michael's popularity will help draw more attention to his case and help the city's gay community realize how much danger they're in.
The case will also raise red flags in neighboring states and finally rouse an ambivalent NYPD into action. From Airship and Evergreen Podcasts, this is episode three in our series on the Last Call Killer.
On the next episode, New York's queer activists sound the alarm and multiple law enforcement agencies come together to form a task force. We used many different sources while preparing this episode.
A few we can recommend are Last Call by Elon Green and the HBO documentary series of the same name. This episode may contain reenactments or dramatized details.
And while in some cases, we can't know exactly what happened, all our dramatizations are based on historical research. American Criminal is a co-production of Airship and Evergreen podcasts.
It's hosted, edited, and executive produced by me, Jeremy Schwartz. Audio editing and sound design by Sean Ruhl Hoffman. Music by Thrum.
This episode is written and researched by Joel Callen. Managing producers are Emily Burke and Sarah Wilgrube. Executive producers are Joel Callen and Lindsey Graham.