Serial Killer: Richard Rogers | A Mutilated Body | 2
Having been acquitted of murdering his roommate Frederic Spencer, Richard Rogers moves to New York City, where he studies nursing and gets a job at Mount Sinai Hospital. But while most nurses dedicate their lives to taking care of others, Richard is that rare creature: an angel of death. Only he doesn't kill his patients. He targets men he meets at Manhattan's gay bars. It's also possible that he's responsible for at least one unsolved murder.
Listen to all 4 episodes of 'Serial Killer: Richard Rogers' wherever you get your podcasts, or to get early, ad-free access to the entire season first, subscribe in Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or at Americancriminal.com
Learn more about your ad choices. Visit megaphone.fm/adchoices
Body Found
This episode contains descriptions and details that some listeners might find disturbing. Listener discretion is advised. It's just past noon on Sunday, April 10th, 1982.
In Orlando, Florida, a 21-year-old man, let's call him Andre, is driving home from church. The services ran long today, and Andre needs to get home so he can change for work.
He's a junior at a local college, and he's been picking up extra shifts so he can graduate as close to debt-free as possible. Luckily for Andre, his mom said he could take her car to save him having to ride the bus.
She'll get a ride home with a neighbor. Only problem with that is that she doesn't like him smoking in the car, and Andre could really use a cigarette right now. Checking his watch, Andre figures out that he's got just enough time for that.
He's supposed to clock in at Arby's by one, so as long as he hustles, he'll be fine. He turns off of Lake Mary Boulevard and onto a quiet dirt road not far from the interstate. He brings the car to a stop, turns the engine off, and gets out.
Taking a few steps away from the road, Andre pulls out a cigarette and is lighter. The wind makes lighting up difficult, so he walks further from the car, hoping to find a better spot.
When he finally manages to get his cigarette lit, Andre feels his whole body relax into the exhale. Then he tenses right back up again. Just a couple of feet in front of him is the unmoving form of a man's body.
Andre is rooted to the spot, staring at a guy who can't be much older than he is. He's got sandy blonde hair, a thick mustache, and his clothes are soaked in blood from what looked like a half dozen stab wounds to his torso.
Deep, purple bruising marks the man's neck. So despite the strange horror of the situation, Andre can't help wondering which was it that killed him, the blade or strangulation?
With that macabre thought going round and round in his head, Andre gets back in the car, cigarettes still dangling from his lips. His mom will just have to get over it. He starts the car again and pulls a U-turn back towards the main road.
He has to find a pay phone to call the police. He's definitely going to be late for work. From Airship and Evergreen Podcasts, I'm Jeremy Schwartz and this is American Criminal.
3:15
Richard Rogersʼ Acquittal
In 1973, Richard Rogers beat his roommate unconscious with a roofing hammer, then used a plastic bag to strangle him to death.
At trial, he told the court that Frederic Spencer attacked him first, so his actions were a simple case of self-defense, and the jury bought it, meaning that 23-year-old Richard was free to go on with his life as if nothing had happened.
But it had happened, and the experience taught him a valuable lesson. He was capable of killing another person. Not only that, but it was all too easy to get away with it.
Despite this, Richard didn't kill anyone else at first. Not that we know of. And by the end of the decade, he was ready for a fresh start, new city, new career.
And with that came the freedom to finally live his life as an out gay man. It might have been this experience that led him to start killing again.
Seeing the way the AIDS crisis affected the gay community and how slow the government was to respond may have taught Richard another lesson. Some lives were valued more than others. Before long, he would put that theory to the test.
But like I said, it's just a theory. I'll let you decide what to believe. This is episode two in our four-part series on the Last Call Killer, Richard Rogers.
It's early winter 1978, five years since Richard Rogers was cleared of murder. Some 450 miles southwest of Arno, Maine, where Frederic Spencer was killed, Richard stands in a long line of people, waiting for his name to be called out.
He's on the roof of One Place Plaza in Lower Manhattan. It's the flagship building for Pace University and where they've held their graduation ceremonies for the past few years.
Standing under a shelf of gloomy clouds, Richard feels a swell of pride as he's invited up onto the stage to receive his diploma. He's worked hard for this, another feather in his cap. He's also looking forward to a fresh start here in New York City.
There's a sense of freedom he's felt ever since he arrived here. No expectations, no judgments. He can be whoever he wants to be.
More importantly, he can do whatever he wants. And no one can stop him. In November of 1973, Richard Rogers was acquitted on charges that he killed Frederic Spencer.
To be clear, Richard did kill Fred. But he convinced the jury that when he used a hammer to hit his roommate in the back of the head eight times and then pulled a plastic bag over his face to suffocate him, it was simply an act of self-defense.
The town Richard lived in when he killed Fred was small, with around 10,000 residents, and plenty of those were students at the college both men attended.
So you would think that a story involving death by hammer and a dramatic courtroom acquittal would grab a lot of attention. Surely, anyone involved with the case would be discussed for at least a couple of days after the trial, maybe even weeks.
But the next time Richard Rogers is mentioned in the RNO newspapers is almost a full year later when he's given a speeding ticket. His name appears in a list of other lead-footed drivers who are each fined 20 bucks. So that's it.
It takes Richard less than 12 months to fade back into the obscurity he enjoyed before he killed Fred Spencer.
Exactly what he spends his time doing isn't clear, but given that he's still living in RNO, I'd assume he carries on with his graduate studies at the University of Maine.
Other than that, the picture we have of Richard from here on out gets murky at best. After he finishes up at grad school, he works as a substitute teacher, teaching French and Spanish to high schoolers.
But something about the role is unfulfilling for him and he eventually decides he's ready for a change. Not just in what he's doing with his life, but where he's doing it. There are any number of reasons Richard comes to this conclusion.
The most obvious is that he just might realize he doesn't enjoy teaching languages as much as he enjoyed learning them when he was younger. Or maybe life as a substitute teacher doesn't suit a man like Richard.
People often describe him as tightly wound and organized to the point of obsession. And he's a quiet sort of guy who tends to keep to himself. Sure, he sings in a church choir, but I don't think you could call him an extrovert.
What I'm getting at is that none of this seems conducive to the life of a substitute teacher, with an ever-changing schedule and a role that almost requires an outgoing personality.
It's also possible that being in the classroom brings back memories of Richard's own high school experience, which was less than stellar.
He used to get made fun of because of his voice, the way he walked, the fact that he never wanted to shower with the other guys after gym, and even because he was in the French club.
So, yeah, there are plenty of potential reasons why Richard decided to stop teaching. As for why he relocates, well, that could have been because of one very specific aspect of his life. I touched on this earlier, but I'll reiterate.
Richard is a gay man, and he's remained in the closet for pretty much his whole life. That's not surprising. He grew up in a religious household, then went to a socially conservative college in a town dominated by Methodist churches.
Plus, it's the mid-70s. Being out is the biggest of deals, even in big cities. So it's highly unlikely that Richard has ever told anyone about his sexuality.
And maybe living with that kind of secrecy is exhausting for him. Maybe he wants to live somewhere that will offer him more opportunities for him to meet other gay men. Maybe go on some dates, take some guys home even.
And right now, New York City is a place where a man can do all of those things and still blend into the crowd. So that's where Richard goes. Starting over in a big city must be daunting for Richard, but he dives right into his new life.
Leaving his language skills in the past, he enrolls in Pace University's nursing program. Figuring it's a stable career path that will offer him the reliable schedule he desires. He does well in the program and graduates towards the end of 1978.
By January of 1979, a now 29-year-old Richard starts working at Mount Sinai Hospital on the Upper East Side of Manhattan. At this stage, he's found an apartment in Yonkers, which is about 11 miles away.
And despite the hour-plus commute, Richard's got an impeccable record for never missing shifts. In fact, he barely uses a sick day or requests time off for the first year he's at the hospital.
That kind of dedication might be why he's promoted to the role of Senior Clinical Nurse in October. The position comes with better pay and a more generous vacation policy, which Richard will start taking advantage of soon enough.
Beginning in June of 1980, when he's been working at Mount Sinai for 18 months, Richard starts taking long annual vacations. He saves up his time off to use all at once, allowing him to go on meandering road trips around North America.
For his first excursion, he takes three weeks to visit Quebec, West Virginia and Massachusetts. Then, it's back to New York to work steadily until the next vacation.
That comes in April of 1981, when he spends about four weeks driving from one side of the country to the other, then back again, hitting up DC, Niagara Falls, San Francisco, Jackson, Boulder and the Grand Canyon.
March of 82 brings another road trip, though he mostly stays in Florida, hitting up Daytona Beach, St. Augustine and Everglades National Park. But the main event of this vacation is Richard's 10-year college reunion.
As class liaison, he wouldn't miss this particular party for the world. But it's just a reunion, nothing life-changing happens there. Now you may be wondering, Jeremy, why are you telling us about every one of this guy's vacations?
Well, I promise there is a method to my madness. In this particular case, some investigators will later suspect that Richard Rogers is responsible for more murders than the ones he'll be conclusively linked to.
The theory, and I should stress that this is a very loose theory, is that Richard uses his long vacations to kill in cities that he visits, and he's gone before anyone knows what's happened.
There are a few cases that people like to speculate Richard was involved in, but perhaps the highest one on the list is the mysterious death of Matthew John Piero.
12:35
Matthew Pierroʼs Murder
At first, investigators have no way to identify the body found on April 10th, 1982. It's left beside a dirt road near I-4 and Lake Mary Boulevard in Orlando. He's about 5'8 and has sandy blonde hair.
His killer stabbed him six times in addition to strangling him. They also bit off one of his nipples, if you can believe it. The only thing in the victim's pockets is a bus ticket from Rochester, New York.
But by circulating descriptions and pictures of him, local police get numerous tips from people who saw a man like that in or near Daytona's gay bars recently.
Using that info, investigators run a photograph in gay magazines, hoping a reader will see it and help them put a name to the face. In the end though, it's the man's fingerprints that lead to his identification.
Prints are sent to the Florida Department of Law Enforcement at the start of the investigation, but they come back without a match.
When local investigators asked the department to look again some months later, they realized they do have a matching set on file. They belonged to 22-year-old Matthew John Pierro.
Back in March, Matthew took a break from his studies to come to Florida to help set up a center for troubled teens. But he left the project after just two or three days, and no one heard from him after that.
On the 15th, he was arrested for sleeping on a park bench and for possessing less than 20 grams of cannabis. Later that month, not long before he was killed, he was jailed on charges of loitering and prowling.
The next time police encountered him was when they showed up to investigate his murder. And even with a name and a trail to follow, the case goes cold and the murder remains unsolved to this day.
Now, it's important to stress that there's no physical evidence linking Richard Rogers to Matthew's death. There's nothing that even suggests they ever met.
But as far as we can tell, no strong suspect is ever investigated in connection with the case. So with the timing of Richard's reunion lining up so closely with the murder, it's tempting to wonder could this have been him?
He was in the state when it happened and as we'll soon see, Richard will develop a habit of mutilating his victim's bodies and we already know that he prefers to dump them beside roads.
Well, if it was Richard who killed Matthew Piero, there's no sign that it affected Richard's everyday life in any way.
Then again, killing Frederic Spencer didn't seem to negatively affect Richard beyond the minor inconvenience of being tried for murder. So if you're asking me, this one's a big fat question mark.
But for now, we'll leave the realm of speculation to focus on what we know. After his 1982 road trip, Richard returns to New York, where he eventually starts working overnight shifts. That means he clocks in at the hospital at 6 p.m. then clocks out at 7 a.m. Having proven himself a dedicated and capable nurse, Richard receives a couple of promotions in the mid-80s. In late 84, he's given the role of operating room nurse.
About a year later, he's moved into the cardiac surgical intensive care unit, where a lot of his job involves working closely with very young children, including newborns.
If you've not spent a lot of times in hospitals, this assignment singles Richard out as a patient-skilled caregiver.
He and a handful of other nurses on the ward have to juggle the constant needs of their patients, which include breathing machines, drug infusions, and careful monitoring of their vitals to spot when something goes wrong.
It's likely a job that Richard finds stressful, so he needs a way to let off steam. For that, he loves country music and Broadway soundtracks.
And on his nights off, he likes to find piano bars where he can have a drink and listen to people belting out show tunes. One of his favorite spots is the townhouse bar, where he's something of a regular.
He's still not great at making connections, though. Plenty of people will recognize Richard, but not know a thing about him. In June of 86, he buys an apartment on Staten Island for about $45,000.
Now, for context, that's about a year and a half to two years' salary for someone in Richard's position. Once he gets that place, his neighbors notice that he's always vacuuming and very occasionally spot him bringing a man home.
And for the first few years that he lives there, all of these dates pass without incident, at least as far as anyone knows. Unfortunately, that won't always be the case.
17:45
Frederic Laro Attacked
It's the evening of July 11th, 1988, a Monday. Manhattan's been sweltering all day, so investment banker Frederic Laro is looking forward to getting inside for a drink. A few minutes ago, he left the New York Health and Racquet Club in Midtown East.
Now, he steps inside the GH Club on 53rd and 1st. The windows of the GH Club are draped with heavy curtains, offering complete privacy from the street outside. A drawer for the regular clientele of more mature, professional gay men.
There's a large U-shaped bar with elaborate flower arrangements at the corners. The soft tinkling of a piano drifts out from a room in the back, underscoring the steady hum of chatter from the customers out front.
Frederic spots a couple of friends at the bar and grabs a stool next to them. He orders a glass of white wine. He catches up with the other men for about 20 minutes or so, and then Frederic notices another guy watching him.
He's leaning against the wall to the side of the bar. He doesn't approach, but when Frederic's friends finish their drinks and leave, the man points at one of the empty stools. A quizzical look on his face.
Frederic nods, inviting the younger man over. Frederic's got maybe 10 years on this guy, who's in his late 30s. He's got a completely unremarkable face, a little round, downturned lips, small eyes, and hair the color of cheap milk chocolate.
He introduces himself as Richard. They get to talking. Frederic and his buddies had been discussing various investment opportunities, and now he and Richard pick up those threads.
Richard says he recently bought an apartment on Staten Island for a great price, just 45 grand. He thinks with a little attention, he could flip it and get nearly double that. Frederic agrees that's a great deal if he can make it work.
That's when Richard invites him to come see the place. Frederic balks, the apartment's all the way on Staten Island, plus it's 8 o'clock on a Monday night. He doesn't really want to leave Manhattan.
But Richard says he's happy to drive them there, and then bring Frederic back here after. So they leave the G&H Club and set off. About 45 minutes later, Richard leads Frederic into the living room of his fifth-floor apartment.
It's impeccably neat, with shelves full of alphabetized VHS cases lining an entire bookshelf along one wall. It's also stiflingly hot, and there's no air conditioning. So Richard offers his guest a drink.
Already feeling himself start to sweat, Frederic asks for something cold and refreshing, like a soda. Richard disappears for a couple of minutes and comes back with a glass of juice. Frederic takes a grateful sip.
He casts about for something nice to say about the bland apartment, but he doesn't get very far into the conversation before the room starts to swirl and spin around him.
Before he can say anything, Frederic feels himself falling forward off the sofa and on to the dark blue rug. When Frederic comes to, he's sure that it's hours later. The noise of the city outside is the muted soundscape of the witching hour.
Most everyone is asleep, but Frederic Laro is being overtaken by a dawning horror. He's lying on his back, his hands and feet are bound together with what looks like hospital ID bracelets, and he's naked.
Struggling against his restraints, Frederic's sleepy mutterings turn quickly into screams. Suddenly, Richard's face looms into view. He looks down at Frederic, tutting quietly as he flicks the plastic chamber off a hypodermic needle.
He leans close, injecting the needle into a vein on the top of Frederic's hand. That'll take care of you for a while, he says. Seconds later, Frederic slips back into darkness.
Later, Frederic Laro will only recall snatches of what happened to him after that. He remembers someone clumsily dressing him. Then he's pushed into the vestibule of his apartment building on 55th Street.
When he's finally lucid enough to pay attention, he's got the key in his hand trying to fit it into the lock. It's dawn, maybe 5.30, 6 o'clock, when he manages to get inside. He calls a close friend and asks them to come over.
He's been attacked and he needs help, he says. That same morning, Frederic and his friend go to the closest police station to report a crime. After that, he heads to Roosevelt Hospital, which these days is known as Mount Sinai West.
Documenting injuries that line up with his story, doctors note that there are bruises on the back of his hand where he was injected. Unsure about what happened to him and scared he might have been exposed to AIDS, Frederic asks for a rape kit.
By this stage, New York has seen around 18,000 AIDS diagnoses in total and more than 12,000 deaths. So it's not surprising that he's fearful. Thankfully, the test results will come back negative.
After that, Frederic waits for something to happen.
It's unclear how much he's able to tell the police about who attacked him, whether he remembers Richard's full name and address, or whether he was just able to offer enough details to lead detectives to the right guy.
But on August 18th, 1988, over a month after the assault, police show up at Richard Rogers' door and place him under arrest. Just how concerned Richard is when he's picked up, I couldn't say. But he's not in custody for long.
He's back at work a couple of days later, two misdemeanor charges pending against him, assault in the third degree, and unlawful imprisonment in the second. Given what he did to Frederic, those words feel so small, so meek.
And Richard likely shrugs them off. He's been accused of far worse in the past and has even confessed to killing a man, and he got away with that. Why shouldn't he get away with this?
It's a long wait before Richard has to stand trial for the assault. The proceedings don't get underway until February of 1990, a year and a half after the incident.
When it comes time for his day in court, Richard and his attorney request a bench trial. This means that a judge will be the sole arbiter of the case instead of a jury.
There are a number of reasons a defendant might request this option, but in cases of sexual assault, the thinking might be that a judge is less inclined to be swayed by emotion or biases than a juror.
In this specific instance, the case involves two men at a time when the queer community is getting a lot of heat because of their increasing visibility, as well as the growing fear and tension surrounding the AIDS epidemic.
So there's no telling who a jury might be inclined to side with. Hence, the bench trial. Right away, Richard's lawyer, Christopher Nally, goes on the attack.
In the months following the incident, Frederic Laro was diagnosed with post-traumatic stress disorder, which has made most social situations exceedingly difficult for him to navigate.
The condition has also made him feel paranoid about other people's actions. Nally highlights that diagnosis for the court when he stands to cross-examine Frederic, hinting that they're dealing with an unstable individual.
Then, he begins pulling apart Frederic's version of events, starting with the timeline of the night, then insinuating that Frederic must have had a lot more to drink at the bar than he first said because he passed out at Richard's apartment.
This is nearly a decade before the use of date rape drugs will be brought to public attention. So it's easy for Nally to cast doubt on Frederic's suggestion that the orange juice Richard gave him was drugged.
He also goes after Frederic's dating habits and sexuality, which is a depressing part for the course when it comes to questioning sexual assault victims in court. He inquires if Frederic remembers asking Richard to tie him up.
Then, he insists that Frederic went to the bar specifically to find a man to take home that night. Frederic denies all of this, and he pushes back when Nally suggests that he suffered no injuries since there was no sign of physical assault.
Psychological trauma isn't nothing, Frederic argues. When Richard takes the stand, he tells a very different version of what happened.
According to Richard, Frederic approached him, struck up a conversation about real estate, and initiated physical contact. When Frederic leaned over to put his arm around him, Richard leaned away, saying that he liked to use discretion in public.
That's when Frederic asked if he could stay the night at Richard's apartment on Staten Island. Frederic's place was no good because he had a nephew staying there.
Richard explains that he drove them out of Manhattan and is careful to tell the court that he's a very cautious driver.
So cautious that when Frederic puts his hand on Richard's leg, he asks him to remove it because he likes to keep his mind on the road. Frederic brought a gym bag to Richard's apartment, which he initially said carried a change of clothes.
But when they got into the bedroom, he opened it to reveal it was full of ropes. He wanted them to try out some bondage together, which Richard wasn't interested in.
After that, Frederic asked if they could have sex, but Richard said that it just wasn't safe, he had to be responsible. That's when Frederic got upset and asked to be driven home. He was angry, saying that Richard had let him on.
This last part seems to be the central piece of the defense, that Frederic concocted a story to get back at Richard for refusing to sleep with him.
So at the end of the three days of testimony, the judge is left with a he-said-he-said argument, and very little physical evidence to support either side.
So he declares that the prosecution has failed to prove the elements of the crime beyond a reasonable doubt, and acquits Richard of both charges. That leaves him free to carry on with his life as if nothing ever happened, again.
For Richard, that means doing his job at the hospital quietly and efficiently. On the evenings he's not working, he likes to visit some of Manhattan's gay bars, where he floats under the radar, largely unnoticed by people.
That's just what he wants because these bars are his hunting ground. And after his most recent acquittal, he's feeling ready to try something new. Richard Rogers is about to begin his terrifying killing spree.
29:29
Peter Anderson Disappears
It's the evening of May 3rd, 1991. On New York's Upper West Side, a large apartment is bustling with mostly middle-aged men and women. The three dozen or so guests are here for a political fundraiser.
Tony Brooks, a handsome young management consultant, is running for a seat on Philadelphia's city council.
Tony isn't out to most people in his hometown, but these log cabin Republicans know his secret, and they're only too happy to contribute to his campaign. The hope is that if he wins, Tony will be a voice for the gay community.
Among the guests is Peter Stickney Anderson. He stands by the front door, directing people's attention to an elegant bowl on a stand where people have been dropping checks all night.
Unlike most of the other people here, Peter actually lives in Philadelphia, and so he has a vested interest in how the campaign turns out. But aside from that, Peter loves any excuse to be social.
Dressed in a three-piece suit, complete with an eye-catching bow tie, 54-year-old Peter waves his drink at people as they walk past, reminding them to donate to the cause.
For most of the night, Peter's been catching up with Anthony Hoyt, an old friend and one-time lover. They haven't seen each other in nearly two decades, so running into one another at a fundraiser for a gay politician is a shock for them both.
Though it's also somewhat on brand for men who felt the need to keep their true selves hidden for most of their lives. Now, as people start leaving, Anthony notices that Peter's slurring his speech just a little. He's not a big guy, Peter.
He stands about 5'4, but he's had at least twice as many drinks as Anthony, and it's starting to show. But aside from a few fumbled words, Peter's remarkably put together, and Anthony's enjoying reminiscing.
So when Peter suggests that they head out to a bar in the city, he agrees. Their decision will turn out to be a deadly mistake. After leaving the fundraiser, Peter and Tony make their way to the Townhouse Bar on East 58th Street.
The place is a quiet, dignified establishment, all deep red wallpaper and leather armchairs, and it sits squarely in the middle of a mostly straight neighborhood.
That makes it a draw for respectable men looking for a place to socialize without fear of harassment from the police. Out-of-towners love the bar, as do handsome young guys looking to be taken care of by older gentlemen.
There's a spacious back room to the townhouse, where a pianist sits playing Broadway standards and American classics all night, usually surrounded by an enthusiastic crowd of regulars. But Peter and Tony don't make it that far into the bar.
They just about get through their first drink before the bartender clocks how drunk Peter is. He refuses to serve them anything else and insists that they leave right away. Tony's relieved it's upsetting to see his friend like this.
He wonders if it was the years of living in the closet that have driven Peter to drink like this. Maybe now that they've gotten reconnected, he can help him get through that. But for now, what Peter needs is to go to bed.
So Tony finds a payphone and calls the Waldorf Astoria. He books his friend a room, then hails a cab for him. The hotel's only about a five-minute drive from the bar.
So when Tony says goodbye to his friend, he figures Peter will be sleeping it off within the hour. Only that's not what happens. Exactly what Peter Anderson does after Tony puts him in that cab isn't entirely clear.
But here's what we do know. He definitely arrives at the Waldorf and goes right up to the check-in counter to tell them his name. He doesn't make it to a room, though.
At some point during the check-in process, he gets a little handsy with the hotel employee grabbing the guy's butt. Now the staff can see that Peter's drunk as all get out, so they cut him some slack.
The guy who got felt up politely explains that staff members are not part of the service. Not in that way. But that he's still welcome to stay here.
Something about this interaction must put Peter off. Maybe he's embarrassed or he's just confused because he walks right back out onto the street. He asks the hotel's security supervisor for directions to Penn Station.
The man tells him where to go and then has to answer a page. And that's the last time anyone sees Peter Anderson alive. Like I said, that's what we know.
What happens to him after that is less clear, to an extent. We don't know where he went after leaving the Waldorf or how many people he spoke to along the way. But we do know what happened to him.
34:42
Peter Anderson Found
It's the afternoon of May 5th, 1991, about 36 hours after Peter Anderson left the Waldorf Historia in New York City. John Siriannia pulls his truck into a rest stop on the Pennsylvania Turnpike.
He's hoping this will be a quick pickup so he can get back on the road. See, John's a maintenance worker for Lancaster County, and he's here to empty the trash cans and make sure the rest area is in good shape.
He climbs out of the truck and heads to the first can. He ties the plastic liner closed, hauls it into the back of his vehicle, gets a new liner settled, and moves on to the next. It's about the third or fourth can when he finds it.
A bag he can easily lift. That's strange because the trash cans here are usually full of soda cans, junk food wrappers, maybe the occasional beer bottle. But this bag, there's something really weighty in it.
And that makes John curious. He grabs a sturdy stick from a nearby patch of trees and starts poking at the black plastic, trying to tear it open. Inside he sees more plastic.
Whatever it is, it's been double bagged. So he keeps jabbing at it, tearing open another layer of plastic. Then another and another and another.
After eight layers of trash bags, John finally reaches the center. He leans closer to get a better look at what he's found. At first, he thinks it's food, a loaf of bread.
But no, that can't be right. Bread wouldn't be that heavy. And then, squinting slightly, he realizes that he's staring at freckles on human skin.
His stomach lurches horribly and he takes a step back. He's just found a human body. From Airship and Evergreen Podcasts, this is episode 2 in our series on The Last Call Killer.
On the next episode, Richard claims at least three more victims in quick succession, leaving authorities scrambling for answers. We use many different sources while preparing this episode. One we can particularly recommend is Last Call by Elon Green.
This episode may contain reenactments or dramatized details. And while in some cases, we can't know exactly what happened, all our dramatizations are based on historical research.
American Criminal is a co-production of Airship and Evergreen podcasts. It's hosted, edited, and executive produced by me, Jeremy Schwartz. Audio editing and sound design by Sean Ruhl-Hoffman.
Music by Throne. This episode is written and researched by Joel Callen. Managing producers are Emily Burke and Sarah Willgrube.
Executive producers are Joel Callen and Lindsey Graham.