Reviews
Rate ShowTop tier true crime pod!
Jeremy Schwartz is an excellent narrator whose voice is soothing, articulate, and easy to understand and follow along with. I subbed after just one episode and I have no regrets. I’ve listened to a lot of true crime podcasts but this one has covered some stories that I’ve never heard before anywhere else. Jeremy doesn’t add any unnecessary banter or biased opinions and just gets right into the story. Much cheaper subscription than most other true crime podcasts out there too. I highly recommend!
- MissGrinch86
- Oct. 19, 2025
Can’t get enough
I’m always so excited for new episodes of American Criminal to drop each week. The series is so well written and researched. Even if I’ve heard a story before, I always learn something new from this show. I can’t recommend it enough.
- MichelleAnne999
- Oct. 15, 2025
Gripping, insightful, bingeable
This series is incredible well produced. The writing is top-notch, with excellent pacing and a demonstration of deep research. Jeremy, the host, delivers the stories with great panache, too. And to top it off, the series presents a variety of different crime stories that always keeps me guessing.
- JohnStuart87
- Oct. 15, 2025
- gianyank
- Oct. 13, 2025
American Criminal is so good
Jeremy Schwartz is an entertaining storyteller. The stories are very well told — I enjoy learning about true crime stories I’ve either never heard of or I only know a little about. I appreciate Jeremy’s occasional sarcasm in these stories. One of my faves!
- Honeybee_MG
- Oct. 2, 2025
Exciting and informative
This style of storytelling, paired with such a voice, makes for a very compelling and engaging experience! I hope it continues!
- lauralandismorefun
- Oct. 1, 2025
- Dmsluck
- Sept. 22, 2025
Excellent
I am so glad I found this show. So well done. I love his voice and how he presents the story. I love all the shows from Airship.
- jsspain
- Sept. 11, 2025
LOVE THIS
Besides knowing this voice personally, it’s the storytelling! So well done! Love how you drop the cited work throughout. Drizzle
- Carlizle My Snizzle
- Sept. 6, 2025
Love it
I was listening to HTDS and heard a preview of AC, so I thought I would give it a try. My first series was Georgia Tan. I binged it and I was hooked. Jeremy Swartz has a fantastic ability to tell a story. I wait (impatiently) for several weeks until the full series is uploaded and then binge it. I really enjoy the extra detail provided by a longer series with multiple parts. As soon as Leopold and Lowe is completed, it will be binged! I highly recommend this podcast.
Absolute and total Fan
I have been hooked on this show ever since the first episode I listened to. The style of Jeremy's story telling plus his intelligence and witty humor plus the facts that the show provides it's a all around 5 plus star show
Great show
Huge fan of the host. He was great in 1865 which turned me on to this podcast. Also a huge fan of American history so this podcast hits multiple levels of interests for me.
- Bobcat fish
- Sept. 1, 2025
Amazing Ride
Loving the show and the shifts in seasons. Never gets old and Jeremy always keeps it interesting.
- Packattack7u
- Aug. 31, 2025
Sooo good!!!
This is such an informative and well-paced podcast, and Jeremy Schwartz’s beautifully gravelly voice is truly the icing on the cake! I look forward to every episode!
- jebisemiju
- Aug. 30, 2025
Amazing podcast!
I would listen to Jeremy Schwartz read me the phone book. I love his personality and his voice is the best. It adds so much to the storytelling. And the stories are great! Well written, tight episodes with just the right amount of detail without dragging out the episode. I listen to a lot of true crime podcasts and AC has covered people and topics I’d never heard before. That’s always a huge bonus for me. I’m always excited to get a new drop of American Criminal in my feed. Keep up the great work, guys! You’re awesome!
- Precipitation
- Aug. 29, 2025
Great Show
This is a great podcast. The storytelling is strong and engaging. I look forward to each new season and enjoying learning more about America’s criminals.
- EM7886
- Aug. 28, 2025
Fantastic true crime pod at its finest
Awesome podcast with no filler and the host has the perfect voice for the job. Keep up the great work!
- Traxonwax
- Aug. 25, 2025
Outstanding Storytelling
Kudos Airship & Jeremy!!! Huge fan of the 1865 podcast and was delighted to find this gem of a narrative voiced by Jeremy. Well researched and well delivered, it will tickle the fancy of any true crime buff out there. Keep up the good work folks. You have a devoted listener here.
- misguided muse
- Aug. 10, 2025
Fantastic Podcast!
I have learned much listening to American Criminal. When I’ve thought I pretty much knew a story, turns out there was lots more to learn. I will never forget about Georgia Tan who I had no knowledge of before listening. Also, I appreciate when you share an episode of another’s podcast which usually leads me to listen to that show as well. These stories are engaging particularly because of Jeremy’s voice and presentation. I actually don’t even mind the commercials. You always come across as sincere.
- KiwiBlock09
- Aug. 5, 2025
Great podcast
First heard Jeremy on 1865 and I was hoping to find if he was doing another podcast and found this. This is an amazing show. Well written, well spoken and keeps me well engaged. Whoever claimed there are no sources….thats not true. They tell you what their sources are when they recommend further reading. Keep up the great work!
- Alternative story
- June 26, 2025
- PW from GR
- Feb. 7, 2025
Better than the rest
Well written, thorough, and entertaining to listen to. Paints a picture that resonates with what you’ve read and know about the subject. And if the subject is new to you there’s no better place to begin to learn. Take your time and savor these episodes!
- Nashville Neil
- Feb. 7, 2025
On top
This is my number one podcast right now because it stands out from all others in a unique and intriguing way of storytelling
- Big d Randy .jr
- Dec. 21, 2024
- Doug P in a Class C
- Nov. 21, 2024